An MDSAP audit cycle is not a single event. It runs through several kinds of audits over time:
- the initial certification audit (split into Stage 1 and Stage 2)
- annual surveillance audits
- recertification audit at the end of the cycle.
- Special or unannounced audits can also happen outside that normal rhythm when circumstances call for them
Depending on the type and nature of audit, these can be conducted on-site, off-site, or in a remote/hybrid mix.
Stage 1: Checking if you are Ready
Once you as the manufacturer has entered into a contract with an Auditing Organization, the first step is a Stage 1 audit. This essentially consists of a documentation review that checks whether you are actually ready to move into the full on-site evaluation. Only once the AO is satisfied that the requirements have been met does the process advance to Stage 2.
Stage 2: Confirming It Actually Works
Stage 2 is where the AO determines whether your QMS and the regulatory requirements in scope are not just documented but effectively implemented. The AO builds an audit plan around the scope of your operations, assigns a qualified audit team, calculates how long the audit needs to run, and works out dates and logistics with you directly.
The audit process
Day one opens with a formal meeting with your representatives. The auditors introduce themselves, confirm the audit scope, criteria, and objectives, and walk through the audit plan so there are no surprises about how the days ahead will go. From there, the audit itself is a mix of document and record review, staff interviews, and a physical tour of your facility. If the evidence does not support a requirement, a nonconformity gets raised. Auditors will typically debrief you periodically throughout the audit, so you are not hearing about a gap for the first time at the very end. The audit closes with a formal meeting where any nonconformities are formally issued on a standardized form (the NGE form) and graded on a 1-to-5 scale using standard grading criteria.
After the Audit: Responding to Findings
Every nonconformity needs a response, though how much documentation that requires scales with its grade. The NGE form is used to communicate your response and AO’s assessment back and forth until the nonconformity is closed. As a general practice, it is worth having your remediation plan for each nonconformity, including root cause, planned corrections, and planned corrective actions, ready within 15 calendar days of the end date of the audit. For the more serious grade 4 or 5 findings, evidence that you have actually implemented the remediation actions is recommended to be provided within 30 days. The AO may come back and verify that implementation, and whether it actually worked, at your next routine audit or occasionally through a dedicated follow-up special audit. If an audit turns up something serious enough — one or more grade 5 nonconformities, more than two grade 4s, a public health risk, or anything fraudulent or counterfeit — the AO is required to flag it to the MDSAP regulatory authorities within 5 working days. This is known as an MDSAP 5-Day Notice.
For more details, see Post Audit Activities and Timeline Policy.
What Happens Behind the Scenes
While you are working through remediation, the AO is independently preparing the audit report, the formal record of how fully your QMS met the requirements, and the core piece of objective evidence behind the whole certification. Once finalized, the AO collates the Audit Report Package for submission into the Regulatory Exchange Platform-secure (REPS), an electronic repository where MDSAP Regulatory Authorities (RAs) can access information to support their pre- and post-market regulatory activities. The Audit Report Package includes:
- The Audit Report, and any relevant attachments
- Any nonconformities that were opened during the audit
- Any open nonconformities where the AO has reviewed the results of the remediation plan
- Evidence of implementation for corrections and corrective actions provided by the manufacturer to remedy any grade 4 or 5 nonconformities.
The AO has 90 calendar days from the end date of the audit to file it. If a 5-Day Notice was triggered, this must be completed within 45 days.
The Outcome
Once the initial audit is successfully completed, the AO issues the MDSAP certificate. This will identify the certification criteria including any applicable RA’s regulatory requirements, the activities performed by the medical device manufacturer, and the devices covered by the certification document.