Substantial equivalence and predicate device are two terms you will be frequently encountering during submission of a 510(k). Let’s try to understand them better.
What substantial equivalence really means
Every 510(k) comes down to one question: is your device substantially equivalent to one that is already legally on the U.S. market? That existing device is called the predicate, and your whole submission is built around the comparison.
There are two ways to approach this:
- Same intended use and same technological characteristics as the predicate.
- Same intended use, but different technological characteristics. In this case, the differences must not raise different questions of safety and effectiveness, and your submission must show the device is as safe and effective as the predicate.
Equivalent does not mean identical. FDA starts by checking that the intended use matches and that any technological differences does not raise new safety or effectiveness questions. Only then does FDA look at how you evaluated those differences and whether your data holds up. That data can include clinical results and bench testing, such as engineering performance, sterility, electromagnetic compatibility, software validation and biocompatibility.
Until you receive a letter finding your device substantially equivalent, you cannot sell it in the U.S. If FDA decides that your device is not substantially equivalent, you can:
- Resubmit a 510(k) with new data
- ask for a Class I or II designation through De Novo
- file a reclassification petition, or
- apply for premarket approval (PMA).
What counts as a predicate
A predicate device is the legally marketed device you compare your device against. Usually, a recently cleared 510(k) device is selected as the predicate device, but it is not the only choice. Any device that is legally marketed in the U.S. can serve as a predicate. That includes devices cleared through 510(k), devices on the market before May 28, 1976 (preamendments devices), and 510(k)-exempt devices. It also includes devices that first entered the market as Class III (through PMA) and were later down classified to Class II or I.
Substantial equivalence to the predicate device is determined by comparing factors such as intended use, design, energy source or delivery, materials, performance, safety, effectiveness, labeling, biocompatibility, applicable standards, and other relevant characteristics.
How to choose a good one
Picking the predicate is one of the most important decisions in a 510(k). It shapes your comparison, your testing, and how the review goes. While selecting a predicate the following points may be considered.
- Well-established testing methods. Predicates cleared using current FDA-recognized consensus standards, FDA guidance, or widely accepted published methods are a safer base than ones that relied on a manufacturer's own internal methods.
- Good performance in the field. MAUDE, MDR and MedSun can show whether adverse events point to a basic design problem.
- No open safety concerns. Check FDA's safety communications for emerging signals.
- No design-related recalls. These can point to a flaw in the design itself, so search FDA's recalls database before you commit.
Steer clear of predicates that depend on outdated methods or superseded guidance. If your only option has a design-related recall, say so up front and document the testing that addresses it.
A few practical points. Confirm that your predicate is legally marketed by reading its public 510(k) Summary and Indications for Use. You can use more than one predicate, for example when your device combines features from several. A reference device can support your submission, but it cannot stand in as the predicate. And explain your thinking while selecting the predicate and reference devices. FDA encourages a short narrative in the 510(k) Summary on how you made the choice.
If two predicates both check every box, track record can break the tie. A device with 15 years on the market over one with 3 years might be a better choice, because its safety history is longer.
Not sure which predicate fits your device? Reach out and we will help you choose.